Disputed

Did Galileo Really Declare His Innocence at Trial?

The defiant words attributed to the father of modern astronomy during his Inquisition trial

I do not hope for any relief, and that is because I have committed no crime.
— Attributed to Galileo Galilei (Father of modern observational astronomy)

Alleged date: Post-1633

A defiant statement during or after his trial.

The Verdict: Disputed — The Source Is Uncertain

While Galileo certainly maintained his innocence during his trial before the Roman Inquisition, the exact phrasing of this quote cannot be confirmed in primary sources. His actual trial records tell a more complex story.

Database Verification Note

Found in 1 providers: gemini

1 source cross-referenced

The Real Story

Galileo's 1633 trial before the Inquisition is one of history's most famous confrontations between science and religious authority. He was tried for advocating the Copernican heliocentric model after being warned not to in 1616. The trial records show Galileo actually adopted a more cautious legal strategy than outright defiance -- he argued he had not intentionally defended heliocentrism and had merely presented it as a mathematical hypothesis. The image of Galileo as a fearless rebel declaring his innocence is partly a romantic embellishment by later writers. The famous 'And yet it moves' ('E pur si muove') attributed to him after recanting is similarly apocryphal, first appearing over a century after his death.
Share this investigation:

More from Galileo Galilei

More Investigations